Delivering Bad News to Executives: The Harsh Reality of SEO in the AI Era
Organic traffic is declining for most SEO clients, with Seer Interactive’s study revealing a 61% drop in click-through rates for queries with AI Overviews. This stark reality is forcing SEO consultants to have difficult conversations with executives, who are watching their dashboards trend downward for months at a time. The art of delivering bad news has become a crucial skill for SEO professionals, and it’s not just about communication – it’s about building trust, providing concrete solutions, and demonstrating expertise under pressure.
Maeva Cifuentes, CEO and Founder of Flying Cat Marketing, has spent 12 years in SEO and has worked with numerous B2B SaaS clients. She emphasizes the importance of surfacing problems early, providing a clear diagnosis, and offering a plan to fix the issue. This approach builds trust and demonstrates a deep understanding of the client’s business. Cifuentes also highlights the need for structured review cycles and deliberate bets with defined expected outcomes, which enables SEO consultants to report on experiments rather than surprise bad news.
The ability to diagnose and provide a plan is critical in building confidence with executives. It’s not just about explaining the problem but also about offering concrete solutions with tradeoffs. This approach empowers clients to make informed decisions and demonstrates the SEO consultant’s expertise and strategic thinking. By focusing on the quality of the diagnosis and the specificity of the plan, SEO consultants can turn a potentially negative conversation into a positive one.
The Unspoken Truths of SEO: What’s Not Being Said
One of the unspoken truths of SEO is that many consultants are not prepared for the conversations that come with declining traffic. They may be skilled at diagnosing the problem but struggle to communicate the solution effectively. This lack of transparency can erode trust and create tension in the client-consultant relationship. Furthermore, the SEO industry’s emphasis on metrics and rankings can lead to a culture of spin and avoidance, rather than honest communication.
Another unspoken truth is that executives are often more interested in the solution than the problem. They want to know what can be done to fix the issue, rather than just being presented with a diagnosis. This requires SEO consultants to think critically and creatively, providing concrete options with tradeoffs rather than vague ideas. By doing so, they can demonstrate their expertise and build trust with their clients.
The pressure to deliver results in SEO can lead to a culture of avoidance, where consultants focus on reporting positive metrics rather than surfacing problems. However, this approach can ultimately damage the client-consultant relationship and lead to a lack of trust. By being transparent and honest about the challenges and opportunities in SEO, consultants can build stronger relationships with their clients and deliver more effective solutions.
Who Wins and Who Loses in the AI-Driven SEO Landscape
The rise of AI Overviews and other AI-driven features in search engines is changing the SEO landscape. Those who adapt quickly and develop strategies to optimize for these changes will win, while those who fail to adapt will lose. B2B SaaS companies that prioritize SEO and invest in expertise and technology will be better positioned to succeed in this new landscape.
On the other hand, companies that rely on outdated SEO strategies or fail to invest in AI-driven optimization will struggle to maintain their online presence. This shift will also create new opportunities for SEO consultants who can develop expertise in AI-driven optimization and provide valuable insights to their clients.
The winners in this new landscape will be those who can provide concrete solutions, demonstrate expertise, and build trust with their clients. They will be able to navigate the complexities of AI-driven SEO and develop strategies that drive results. The losers will be those who fail to adapt, prioritize short-term gains over long-term success, and neglect to invest in expertise and technology.
The Skeptical Case: What Could Go Wrong
One potential risk in the AI-driven SEO landscape is that consultants may overemphasize the importance of AI Overviews and neglect other critical aspects of SEO. This could lead to a narrow focus on optimizing for AI-driven features, rather than developing a comprehensive SEO strategy. Additionally, the increasing reliance on AI-driven optimization may lead to a lack of transparency and accountability in the SEO industry.
Another risk is that the emphasis on AI-driven SEO may lead to a lack of investment in human expertise and creativity. As AI-driven tools become more prevalent, there may be a temptation to rely solely on technology rather than human judgment and expertise. This could lead to a lack of nuance and sophistication in SEO strategies, ultimately harming clients and the industry as a whole.
What’s Next: The Verifiable Event to Watch
One key event to watch in the AI-driven SEO landscape is the continued development and refinement of AI Overviews and other AI-driven features in search engines. As these features evolve, SEO consultants will need to adapt their strategies and develop new expertise to remain effective. Additionally, the increasing importance of AI-driven optimization will create new opportunities for innovation and disruption in the SEO industry.
Another key event to watch is the growing demand for transparency and accountability in the SEO industry. As clients become more sophisticated and aware of the complexities of SEO, they will increasingly demand more transparency and accountability from their consultants. This will create new opportunities for consultants who can demonstrate expertise, build trust, and provide concrete solutions.
Bookmark this one — it will matter to your business decisions this week.
By Priya Nair, AI & Startup Reporter at TrendFlashy
Ready to launch your own asset?
Check out our guide on Building a Profitable Online Business.
